10 Excerpts from Sheldon Pollock’s interview to Tehelka
The following are excerpts from an interview that Sheldon Pollock, currently the head of the Murty Classical Library of India gave to Tehelka some time in 2011. Videos of the interview titled “Sheldon Pollock on Hindutva and the Life and Death of Sanskrit” are available in two parts at the following links:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VXhInNUVZ6U
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mk8WVyyyst8
Items in italics are verbatim quotes from Prof Pollock.
[contextly_sidebar id=”NhBWID0yXkIxLpVIVUXrYLfWHukkGcbo”]
- Sheldon Pollock mentions that he took up Sanskrit Studies as part of his interest in Classical Studies. As a classicist he wished to co-opt Sanskrit with Latin and Greek studies.
- ‘Saraswati came to my dream, and asked me to be her lover.’
- The Mahabharata speaks of fratricide and in a way symbolizes civil war.
- The Ramayana can be seen as sort of creating others.
- Pollock compares Hindus’ “fascination” with Sanskrit with the fascination of Jews with Hebrew, and the Catholic’s fascination till recently with Latin.
- He mentions that Japanese Buddhists reciting Sanskrit Sutras ‘without understanding them’, and also claims that there was a debate in medieval India if Vedic mantras were needed to be understood for efficacy.
- Sanskrit was a very elegant language for poetry and philosophy.
- ‘You know this whole spoken Sanskrit movement fills me with a kind of nausea. The point is not to be able to go out in the streets of Bangalore and order a cup of chai in Sanskrit, the point is to establish serious phi-logically grounded, historically-sensitive, theoretically …self-aware scholarship on Sanskrit to make it into an instrument of the creative preservation of the past and creative critique of the past.’
- Pollock speaks about how unlike Europe where Philosophy was separate from mythology and poetry, the great Indian philosophers were also great poets and mythologists.
- Everyone speaking Sanskrit is an insane idea






The editor of this article has neither read the works of Pollock, nor it seems like he will understand them, even if he reads them. Picking out some lines out of the context and out of the general arguments that Pollock’s research makes shows this. Try to understand the the argument in the book, dear editor. This book peddles the same old orientalist arguments about India: that India is priest-ridden, casteist, immoral culture. Thanks for spreading such views in the name of India facts.
Inviting the wolves to guard the sheep, eh?
I’m glad we have another firang who will continue teaching us about our “glorious” past. They should have Witzel come down from Harvard as well for guest lectures. That would be truly awesome.
Please, please do not waste our precious resources on this library. I hope Modi does not announce some financial support from taxpayers’ money.
Infosys is the industry’s largest land owner. They seem to own prime land in every Indian town.
Murthy has always been an overrated “champion of industry”.
Looks like the wheel has now turned full circle and he is ‘giving back’ to society. Only, it looks more like revenge than gifts!