Narendra Modi reawakens India to its ancient civilizational tryst

(This article appeared in the souvenir released at Madison Square Garden for Prime Minister Modi’s visit. Emphases added)

When Shri Narendra Damodardas Modi gave his first speech in parliament he spoke of the end of 1200 years of slavery. Indeed it felt that India had arisen to a new dawn, a “tryst with destiny” that it had not quite kept when it awoke to the midnight hour in 1947.  When an extraordinary man from a very ordinary background took oath as the Prime Minister of India at the culmination of the world’s largest election, not many Indians remained unmoved.

Not that his journey was easy. It had all the makings of a hero’s tale. The story of a young boy who sold tea, who lived in a one room house, who swam a crocodile infested lake, captured the imagination. The diligent karyakarta, the worker, who evaded arrest during the dark hours of the emergency by passing off as a Sikh, and the popular community organizer who became the Chief Minister of Gujarat as a first time Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA). In all Indian epics there is a period of exile, of separation, of trial by fire. Rama had vanvasa, fourteen years of wilderness, Arjuna endured exile and before Modi could be Prime Minister he too underwent years of trial by fire.

Modi’s agni-pariksha came after the dark days of violence in Gujarat. There was hardly a politician in India more vilified in an internationally orchestrated campaign of calumny fanned by a partisan elite. Witnesses were coerced, false accounts paraded, quotes were made up all with the intent to get one man. Though the Gujarat administration under Modi put up one of the most robust responses against communal violence in modern India, the motivated campaign continuously built upon referencing its own falsehoods.  The law courts and ultimately, the people’s court, repeatedly sided with truth and justice. As his party’s campaign slogan famously said, the more mud you throw, the more the lotus will bloom. And bloom it did as Modi overcame the barriers of the English-class of India, which looked down upon someone who did not speak the Queen’s English, the campaign of hate, the barriers of poverty and caste and captured the people’s heart and imagination.

modi 1

On Modi’s election campaign, his connect with the people of India was palpable. Here was a politician who was not lecturing the people but empathizing with their sorrows and difficulties. Not reading from a script but reading the audience. And unlike most of those who had ruled India since independence, he did not need to do photo ops outside a poor man’s hut, or “poverty tourism” as he labelled it, he had experienced deprivation first hand.

Of course, victory is the start, not the end of the challenges. India’s problems are vast, compounded by an archaic colonial state apparatus that was never intended for the benefit of India’s people. The Indian state remains a colonial state. It was designed for a singular purpose—extortion and control. The officer at the district level is called a ‘collector’, marking his primary function. The bureaucrats were trained to identify with the civilization of the rulers and look down on the natives. The elected representatives acted like feudal lords. We gained independence but we never became free. Since the system — executive, judiciary, police — was never designed for us, we found ways to get around, to circumvent it, to corrupt it. We never dismantled the colonial state to create a Government for the people. The dynastic rule at the top of the pyramid was embedded into the status quo, its courtiers and darbaris keeping the masses at bay with the dangers of Hindutva and the glories of English while sipping Chianti in Lutyen’s Delhi.

Here was a politician who was not lecturing the people but empathizing with their sorrows and difficulties.

With Modi at its helm, India has embarked on the journey of reconnecting with its civilizational roots. But as Swami Vivekanda famously said, you cannot teach the Gita to a hungry man. So Modi is rightly focused on economic growth as a priority.  It is best to understand India as a redeveloping nation. Just a few hundred years ago it was one of the richest countries and with forward looking policies and clear thinking there is little reason why it cannot get there again. This is an area where Indian Americans, can make significant contributions. India needs investments across the board, from capital to human talent and NRIs and PIOs can play an important part.

From the ramparts of the Red Fort Prime Minister Modi declared himself to be a servant of the people. A tireless worker, the effect of his personal work ethic is reverberating across his ministers and bureaucrats. Rather than sauntering in towards noon-time after a game of golf officials are expected to show up on time to office.  Rather than leaving at 5 pm, they are seen working till 9 or 10 pm. Clearly the Prime Minister’s seriousness about making the change is rubbing off.

modi 15th

While Modi was in the US, there are a few things he could take away from there. One is studying the effectiveness of local government in the US. While the people of India have voted for transformative government at the national level, most of their problems are local. People end up calling their MP for problems like water, sewage, sanitation and roads.  This is because government in India remains highly centralized as was intentionally setup by the British. Revenue and expenses are not managed locally. The local police is responsive in the US because it reports to the city mayor who is elected directly by the people. The accountability loop is small. There is no gargantuan state-level bureaucracy as in India where the police hierarchy reports all the way to the chief minister.  The same is true for public schooling. Many people in the US send their children to public schools since they function reasonably well, unlike in India, where anyone who can afford it, looks to send their children to private schools. The schools, too, are locally managed and locally funded, making them far more responsive and accountable to the people. In India, schools are part of the state-level structure and teachers look at rural areas as “hardship postings”. Democratizing and decentralizing government functions in India is essential.

With Modi at its helm, India has embarked on the journey of reconnecting with its civilizational roots.

The second issue is that of language. Many prosperous countries around the world teach engineering, medicine, law and business in their own languages. In India, English is required to practice in the Supreme Court and most High Courts and for all professional education. This has become a barrier for India’s progress. English is an asset but the country needs to also provide equal opportunities for Indian language learners.

The opportunity we have and the dream we see is not just of a change of government but a restoration of our civilizational trajectory. India was a center of learning. There are records of conferences happening in Kashmir where scholars from South East Asia and China participated. Indians sought after knowledge and evidence of that is still found in the Indians that populate the US as professors, doctors and scientists. And we are entrepreneurial as Indians running everything from hotels to Silicon Valley startups to fortune 500 corporations’ show. For too long, the Indian system itself has suppressed the genius of the Indian people.  In a world riven by religious strife, the ancient pluralism and the notion of sarve bhavantu sukhina, let all be happy, shows a path. Millions of Americans today practice yoga, but that is just the tip of the iceberg of Indian wisdom in how to lead a healthy, happy, balanced life in harmony with the planet. With the ascension of Modi as Prime Minister, people of Indian origin throughout the world sense the possibility of India resuming its path of knowledge and wealth creation and the guru of spiritual wisdom. The world will be better for it.

msg photo  msg photo 2

The author can be followed on Twitter @sankrant and blogs at http://sankrant.org.

Sankrant Sanu is an entrepreneur, author and researcher based in Seattle and Gurgaon. His essays in the book “Invading the Sacred” contested Western academic writing on Hinduism. He is a graduate of IIT Kanpur and the University of Texas and holds six technology patents. His latest book is “The English Medium Myth.” He blogs at sankrant.org .
  • Manoj

    Unbelievable read! Awesome. Thank you for this!

    By the way, do you have any inside sources in PMO to give this feedback.

  • Intellectual Kshatriya

    India was never a slave of anyone as it says here 1200 years of slavery. India was never a slave. You need to better understand India. India is a continent disguised as a country. Indian history is not uniform unlike US and UK. Indian history consists of several regional histories. India itself is not a uniform entity.

    Now, in terms of so-called British rule, India was never ruled by anyone. British occupation and intervention is called “British Rule”. There is no such thing as “British Rule” but “British Intervention”. For example, America has occupied Afghanistan but Afghans are never going to and will never say that the Americans ruled over us for 30+ years. British occupation of India for 100+ years is the same as American occupation of Afghanistan at the present moment (i.e. October 2014) Similarly, Indians should never say that the British ruled over us. Moreover, it also has a negative psychological impact on a person if he/she is taught that someone came and ruled over you.

    There was a time when France had a lot of influence over England for 100+ years, but the English people never say that the French ruled over us or the Italians (Romans) ruled over us. Similarly, India needs to rewrite its own history.

    You can watch this video to get a clear understanding of what I am talking about: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SmqxkkZtK8k&list=UUX7SHIccUCj3S4cID-pM-Xg

  • harihara

    he is doing the pravachan and prasaar;Whether that along with the life style in harmony with the precepts will take place in a market culture which has eaten life styles in recebt times an the lack of convictions an confusion of the 1000 years -is anybody’s guess But oes anyone care

  • Narasimha

    My heartfelt congratulations to you, Sankrant Sanu. A great article. I am circulating to some of my friends group. I read your articles in Sulekha.com and the victory over Wendy Doniger. Please keep posting we need writers like you.

  • Guest

    Uninformed (yet opinionated) Modi bhakts can barely cope with the current facts, let alone be wise enough to comprehend history in the correct context.

    • SB

      Yes, you are right. Poor Bhakts.
      The “correct” context must be the one which Goddess Romila Thapar and her minions provide.

      • Guest

        Uninformed, yet opinionated!

        Hindutva Taliban did their best to destroy the nation & it’s leadership. Now singing paeans to Mahatma Gandhi and Sardar Patel to fool the gullible.

    • Vishnu

      It’s nice to see a dissenting comment on these boards. It proves that IndiaFacts does not censor the dissenting voices. Unlike some left-wing websites I’ve been to where only positive comments will be allowed on the discussion boards. Respect to the IndiaFacts moderators.