Opposing the Left is Not “Right”-Part II: More to Mahishasura

I specifically favor nationalism when I make a call to the State to investigate and persecute these left ideologues.

A debate ensued, which led me to write another post on February 19: This time it was it was for all and sundry. I am reproducing it in entirety for you to read:

After I posted my earlier piece as call [to] the students comparing left-wing thinking to the asuras, which I wrote not from the position of a right-wing thinker but from the positional of a critical thinker and an academic, I was not aware that some of the left-wing ideologues in JNU have actually been worshipping the demon or the asura “Mahisasur” on campus.

It actually lends a lot of credibility to my thesis. Whereas I do not question their right to worship whoever or whatever in accordance with the constitution of India, I do want to take the opportunity of raising awareness among my fellow Indians with regards to the deeper occult significance of this.

Secondly, as I reflect further on some of the slogans that were shouted on JNU campus on February 9, my thesis gets substantiated even more. So let us look at some of the February-9-JNU-campus slogans: “Bharat Tere Tukde Honge,” meaning India, you will be fragmented; “Ek Afzal maroge, ghar ghar afzal paida honge” meaning if you kill one Afzal, there will be Afzal from every home.” These slogans are not merely against a State, which in their opinion is oppressive or just a celebration of a jihadist. It is much more sinister and evil than that.

afzal guruScholars who are engaged in academically understanding the spiritual heritage of India will know and understand that in the cosmic scheme of things, the demoniac, hostile, and evil forces are forces representing fragmentation, disharmony, and rupture. That is why there is a call to fragment India. What is even more interesting is that they are using the term Bharat for India—a term which both the Jihadists and leftists are not known to use. The reason that they are using it in this context is because they are targeting Bharat Mata, which again from the account of many spiritual figures primarily Sri Aurobindo, is a spiritual figure representing forces of unity, harmony, and spirituality.

Now let us come to understanding the occult behind the second slogan. For those of you, who have read about the demon Raktabeeja, you would know that this demon multiplied as many times as its blood drops fell on earth. These slogan shouting leftists and jihadists combined are invoking the hostile, negative, and demonic forces behind the asura (demon) Raktabeeja when they sloganeered in favor of Afzal.

The significance of all this is much deeper, which unfortunately will get lost in the freedom of expression vs. nationalism debate, not that the debate is not necessary. But look at the debate itself. It began with most of the English media anchors like Barkha Dutt (from NDTV) and Zaka Zacob (from CNN IBN) taking the side of freedom of expression—only Arnab Goswami from Times Now TV took a different stance, when he actually nailed the JNU students who were participating in the debate.

Due to the public outrage at the anti-India slogans, backed by the arguments of many that the Indian constitution does not guarantee an absolute freedom of expression, some of these media people backed off. But then they took off on a different track: linking this public outrage siding with Nationalism with the rise of Fascism.

Now before I proceed further, let me make an important distinction: there will be some in the Indian left-wing who will be ignorant and some will be outright evil. The ones who have been explicitly supporting the bloody ideologies of Naxalism, Maoism, and Jihadism are outright evil or asuric. Others are ignorant, whose vision does not go beyond the self-righteous goals of left thinking and an extreme hatred for anything spiritual, which comes largely from what is now called the Hindu thought.

I give it to them that they are bleeding-heart “intellectuals” and good-hearted people but they have not gone beyond the confines of left thought, and have most certainly not extensively explored the Indian spiritual traditions by having spent time to know the rationale of why the Indian spiritual traditions proposed what they did—the disagreement with it is not the issue here; what is at stake is an academic and intellectual exploration and understanding. The above issue, which I have just mentioned is a huge topic, worth covering in many books. Therefore I will stop here and come back to the earlier point that I was making.

Asura or the negative hostile forces operates through both: ignorance and evil. And that is why you will almost always find left-wing supporting the causes of these undivine forces engaged in the process of fragmentation and division—it almost always happens in the name of ideals. And it is behind these high ideals that it avoids the scrutiny of an incisive intellect.

Therefore what I am suggesting here:

1. The State at this point in time should act tough and go after these outright evil students, activists, academics, and intellectuals who have any connection with the violent groups—whether it is Naxals, Maoists, or Jihadists.

2. For the others, the ignorant ones, it should ensure that they are unharmed and should be allowed their academic freedom and freedom of expression. Clamping down on them or on JNU or any other academic institution is not the solution. But the State should ensure that there are institutions that explore the traditional Indian thought that can challenge the left-wing thinking in the spirit of academic freedom and debate. The State should ensure that it does not harm the non-violent left intellectuals but it should also ensure that these left-wing intellectuals shun their academic fascism by allowing voices that challenge them in an academic setting—there is a strong need of creating institutions of eminence which teach social sciences through prisms other than those of the left-wing.

For far too long, the left-wing intellectuals have enjoyed the patronage of State for promoting the Nehruvian-Marxian-left ideology and clamping down on anyone who differs from them by right away putting them in the extreme Hindu camp. Then they link the budding intellectuals with Nero or fascists or Gujrat violence, and that is where the story ends. There is always the support of most English media, and they happily and gleefully go back home celebrating their unknown fascism, having killed dissent and difference of opinion. The classical Indian traditions have a long history of very sophisticated intellectual arguments, which have been almost totally killed by the left-wing fascists in India. This is what the left-wing does to dissent and difference of opinion coming from the classical Indian traditions, necessarily in the same order: Hindu, Brahmanical, RSS-BJP, Gandhi Killers, Gujarat violence, Nero, fascists, Nazis.

So my dear fellow Indians, if you think that you have won the freedom of expression vs nationalism debate, let me tell you point blank: YOU HAVE YET AGAIN BEEN FOOLED BY THE ASURA. This asura is much devious than you can gather. It knows that it has lost the debate of freedom of expression vs nationalism debate.

So, now it will lie low for some time. It will look for some scuffle here and there so that it can link it up with extremism and fascism. In fact, it has already begun demonizing your nationalism by linking it with fascism and Nazism. This “mayavi” asura, operating through evil and ignorance, will demonize everything spiritual that you may be wanting to do.

The demon is hiding in the left-wing thinking, working through outright evil and fooling the ignorant. And because there are many nice hearted ignorant people in the grip and clutch of the asura, the best approach for the governance should be to create academic institutions of eminence where the nice-hearted, well-meaning left intellectuals can be engaged through an academic spirit of inquiry and shown a different light where they can transcend and integrate their idealism and desire to create a beautiful world for something larger and better.

Analyzing the above

Any individual who is not ideologically blind will see that the above two pieces are transcending the binary of freedom of expression vs. nationalism, in which the debate of TV channels got bifurcated. I have explicitly stated that the “significance of all this is much deeper, which unfortunately will get lost in the freedom of expression vs. nationalism debate, not that the debate is not necessary.” So on one hand I say that the deeper significance of this issue will get lost in the freedom of expression vs. nationalism debate but on the other hand, I also say that the debate is necessary.

I specifically favor nationalism when I make a call to the State to investigate and persecute these left ideologues, who have explicit connection with violent groups. On the other hand, I strongly tilt towards freedom of expression when I clearly state that the State should ensure that the good-hearted and good-spirited left intellectuals are not harmed in any which way and that it should ensure that their freedom of expression and academic freedom does not come under any cloud. I make it a point to emphasize that clamping down on JNU is not the solution.

On the contrary, the State should take measures to establish institutions of eminence where classical Indian spiritual traditions are taught. I am not in any way or form for reducing the plurality or diversity in ways of knowledge pursuit. On the contrary, I am all for promoting and proliferating it. I am certainly against is is the fascism of the Indian left, which begins to tarnish dissent always by linking it with extreme Hindu right. This is a dangerous trend in India, and it is important that the academics in India should know about and raise their voice against.

I do not understand if this is not liberal thinking, then what is!

[The two posts led to a vigorous debate between Prof. Kundan and a Facebook friend who is a mainstream journalist in India.  This will be the 3rd part of these series.]

Author of “The Evolution of Integral Yoga: Sri Aurobindo, Sri Ramakrishna, and Swami Vivekananda,” and several other edited-book chapters like “Beyond Mind: The Future of Psychology as Science” “Beyond Postmodernism: Towards a Future Psychology,” “Relativism, Self-Referentiality, and Beyond Mind,” and “Relativism and Its Relevance for Psychology.” Kundan Singh, PhD is an academic who teaches and lectures in the San Francisco Bay Area. He is a graduate of the California Institute of Integral Studies and University of Delhi.
  • Madhan

    After reading all this, the conclusion is, a street flower vendor (entrepreneurial mind) has a more pragmatic, practical, and common sense than these academics.

  • Kundan Singh

    My yesterday’s (March 4) Facebook post on the Kanhaiya event: Nazis took our dharmic swastika, inverted it, and committed one of the worst reported crimes in human history. The moral of the story: Asuras are masters at inverting so as to deceive. This guy Kanhaiya right in front of our eyes inverted the azadi slogans in which previously the secession of Kashmir was sloganeered for (whether Kanhiya was involved in those slogans or not is a matter for court to decide but there is no doubt that secession of Kashmir slogans were shouted on JNU campus) and made them into azadi-in-India slogans. We Indians have come so far away from our spiritual cosmology that most of us have even lost the capacity to see what is really going on. I do not think Kanhaiya is aware of the forces that are working behind him but it is only a matter of time that ignorance (avidya) through which the hostile forces act will make him the toast of the nation.

  • Rajesh K

    This all is the result of Indian Curriculum. A whole lot of Communists.

  • Indian

    Must see about ASURA LOONS HUMANITY

  • Kraken

    A must-read article regarding “Mahishasura Martyrdom Day”,

  • Indian




    3. EVERYTHING IS NOTHING AND SOMETHING: HA HA HA, a nice story about RED RAT MAO, somebody came to Mao showing a Pic of a Lady who had lost her only son for the cause of ASURAS. The Head ASURA Mao’s political philosopher replied “Everything is nothing, facts are a biggest superstition planted by BOURGEOIS (SO BOURGEOIS BECOMES A NON VIOLABLE “FACT”),how does she know that the son existed?”

    4. WAR IS PEACE: Now this is NOT superstition BUT A FACT


  • Indian

    Here is the Partial List of the ASURA Loon Goon squad, of ONLY the bastard christian Kanhaiya Ilk, Maoism, on conservative estimates 260 million people lost their life in “Most Humane way in Love” butchered in ‘Humanism” by “progressive” ASURAS just to keep the deranged degenerate Asura Mao in Power. Specially the “PROGRESS’ of Great Leap Forward to reduce China to stone age

    Also now the ASURAS LOON-GOON squad have started new barking. with names like Religion vs Science, Rationalism etc. Double Speak and Double Think of the Loons DO YOU SEE ANY SCIENTIST, ENGINEER, TECHNICIAN,SOLDIER, etc in this ASURA squad? NIL. Most of these so called intellectuals (First step should be stop calling them intellectuals) are some third rate BAs, 12th etc in Political Sciences, Journalism, arts, women studies….and other parasitic gutter subjects which is a Huge Waste on Tax Payers Money, producing the degenarate, deranged stream of gutter pigs in human clothing who offcourse frequent the parties of Super Rich ready to lay their daughters for mass orgies, for a smile for some crumbs to be thrown at them. In fact JNU may not be closed as its not easy, BUT Commie Dogs should be asked to finance these Parasitic streams and their money sources properly audited
    One Thing all Hindus,etc HAVE TO KEEP IN MIND. COMMUNISM IS A BASTARD PROGENY OF WESTERN XTIAN CHURCH-THE HEAD ASURAS OF WORST KIND. THESE PROFESSIONAL SMEARRASCALS HAVE NOT EVER ATTACKED BIB-LIE OR WESTERN XTIANITY But bedded it to produce incestuous prdts, which has RAVAGED ONLY NON WESTERN NON XTIAN “CIVILIZATIONS’ FOR WESTERN “GUTTER NON CULTURE” . These ASURAS have never had ANY role in anti colonial struggle of ANY COUNTRY but licked the pots of of whites colonial masters. They emerge from the shitholes LIKE SHIT NEMATODES infecting the body as soon as they get a chance

  • Megh

    Thank you Kundan Singh for your piece and for the thought “…there is a strong need of creating institutions of eminence which teach social sciences through prisms other than those of the left-wing.”

  • Indians(IMO muslims, christians or communists are not Indians), why are you paying taxes which is used by the GOI to keep shithole(communist) institute JNU named after a bastard afloat which manufactures shit like mahiasura divas.

    Should you not boycott taxes or rather exercise your right as Indian and hold GOI accountable as the tax you pay is being used to weaken Hinduism?

    Do Indians pay taxes to strengthen their enemies?

    How this fake story based on Aryan invasion theory was used against Hindus?

    The Asur Tribe which used to celebrate Durga Festival for thousands of years now celebrate Mahiasura divas because of JNU propaganda.

    Courtesy: Omega Man – While 71.6% of Asurs considered themselves as Hindus in census of 1961, only 48% did so in 1981 because many have converted to christianity as they dont worship Goddess Durga now believing the lies of JNU.

  • guest

    left-wing supporting the causes of these undivine forces engaged in the process of fragmentation and division—it almost always happens in the name of ideals. And it is behind these high ideals that it avoids the scrutiny of an incisive intellect.

    Clear, concise, and correct!!

    All our efforts should be at highlighting the fact that the core of the issues gets sidetracked in way asuras deal with this debate. Indian traditions provided a composite, unique way of looking the world, which, in my opinion, is more universal than the west’s way, where there basic limits on ‘how time is considered’ (linear vs. cyclical)

  • Shreevalsan

    The simplest solution for Modi is to close down JNU and save a lot of taxpayers’ money. And send the parasitical ‘students’ home.

  • Indian

    They use our own virtues our own laws by stretching them to limits, FoE GUTTER DOG DEGENERATE SITARAM YECHURY which Commie country had FoE. Oh the so Humane Pol Pot “progressives’ which practiced zero civilization, Stalin and Pol Pot, Mao the greatest humanists who killed 600 million people in humane Bloodbaths. Created PEOPLES KGB AND STASI for most repressive apparatus. The 100 flowers Bloom bastard we see 100 flowers in Bengal and Kerala where other flowers including toddlers are killed because they belong to different Bloom
    There are NO TWO WAYS these 0.09% vote plague rats HAVE TO BE CULLED. India’s situation is like Malaysia in 1969, Indonesia before Suharto, France during De Gaulle time AND WITHOUT VIOLENCE NOTHING WILL BE ACHIEVED. INDIAN GOVT HAS TO CREATE DEATH SQUADS AND IF THEY DO NOT “WE THE PUBLIC” HAVE TO GO FOR MOB AND ANY OTHER TYPE OF VIOLENCE.

  • Indian

    Wrong Sir 1. Neither they are Good people neither Intellectuals, These are the bastardized products of Soviets Chinese EU, British Portuguese and keeps and street sluts whose mothers liked it 4 in 1 21600 times a day (freq of breathing). These Loons are Not Drs, Engineers, Scientists, Farmers, Soldiers But a bunch of degenerates loons of parasitic persuasion, good for nothing products of slut bedding. Can you see that all of them seem to be filthy Bengali crosses between monkey and dog, these Loon Goons survive and feast on OUR VIRTUES, OUR TOLERANCE, professional scum traders. Their psychology is simple, “CREATE GUILT WHERE THERE IS NONE” because these shitfleas survive on YOUR FEELING OF GUILT. These street dogs hide their Italian Red kacchas behind Kurtas, with Condom brigand overused oversized rancid smelly Commie C.. looking Covered. They are good for nothing two bit brainless pseudo intellectuals The professional low life Muckcreaters doing some 6 months diploma in gutter course of jounalism (which even pigs can do in 6 mins but its beyond pig dignity to do it) or some BA s in useless subjects like Political Science, humanities SURVIVING on OUR TAX MONEY.,These are degenerate rabid maddogs who bed their mothers, daughters, sisters, fathers, brothers in the name of SEXUAL FREEDOM. these parasite nematodes wriggling in pigshit, through mother, daughter raping media degenerates of 2 peg persuasion live on OUR VIRTUES OUR MONEY OUR TAXES, while negating all which everybody knows is good. They will loot and SURVIVE ON OUR VIRTUES because these good for nothing gutter pigs,street dogs are useless pieces of prdcts of maniacal sluts and sexcrazed pigs of white SKIN, while make you feel guilty FOR your Virtues your goodness and will want you to prepare your pyre and jump on it for the same reason. WHAT HAS THE LUNATIC Communist Red maddogs given except those Bloodthirsty Draculas like EMS Jyoti Basu in India. In Kerala nobody will work Red Flags et-al, while the same Keralite is goes as a slave to Gulf cleaning gutters 16 hrs a day, while these slave traders loot their money and women and sell them to their White and Arab masters. Bengal is the biggest RED LIGHT AREA on World after Italy because of these Human Traders, the Lod mouth cowardly uncultured bengali lout will act smart in India but grovels like a slave offering his women at the sight of white masters. COMMIE DOUBLESPEAK : Poverty is prosperity; War is Peace; Intellect does not exist; Everything is something and nothing; Freedom is Slavery. WHY WORKERS PARADISES WERE FACED WITH WORKERS REVOLUTIONS AND SUBSEQUENT GENOCIDES BY THESE STREET DOGS, BECAUSE COMMUNISM PLACES A PREMIUM ON PIGS AND DOGS. FIRST LEVEL ALWAYS OF PIGS (Yes Mr Sitaram Yechury you said correctly even dogs can do asanas, YOU LOVE PIGS YOUR MASCOT BECAUSE ITS THE ONLY ONE WHO LAYS HIS MOTHER AND DAUGHTER LIKE YOU COMMIES)