Do Indians prosper only abroad?
The idea that Indians do well abroad and are held back at home is an oft-repeated conviction in its city salons. Indeed the common man has also heard of glittering Indian successes abroad and suspects that all is not well at home, where it is apparently hard to get ahead. The implied conclusion is that India must imitate countries that have allowed Indians to succeed. In fact, the country most have in mind is the US, from which stories of dramatic Indian successes mostly emanate. Other countries like the UK, Australia some in Europe and even Singapore figure, but it is the US that exercises the greatest fascination for the Indian imagination.
The success of their fellow countrymen admired and envied take the shape of large homes, swank cars, cool attire and that prized accent that distances the proud speaker from bumpkin cousins at home. Who will have not heard some self-conscious American drawl in an Indian restaurant and not felt obliged to react with unspoken deference against one’s better judgement?! But who are these ethereal NRI Indians one is compelled to enquire if the slightest social scientific understanding of the phenomenon is to be attained.
The nature of the success abroad provides its typology, ranging from easy excellence in examinations and the professions to business and a smidgen of public office appointments in recent years. The most obvious question that arises is whether or not similar stories of personal advancement in India can be found despite all its travails? India has its Reliance, Wipros and Infosys and myriad other successes. There is no shortage of lawyers like Harish Salve and whiz kid accountants, doctors and Sridhars in the professions and public service. Indeed countless Indians have quietly enriched themselves in the two odd decades after liberalisation began in 1992. Clogged city roads are full of high end cars and the prices charged in restaurants and malls make even the visiting NRI gasp in shock. Some Indians can obviously afford this overpriced life style.
United States lightship WAL 539 painted for station “OVERFALLS” in Lewes, Delaware (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Unnoticed in the past decade, NRIs no longer automatically feel they have much higher spending power when they visit India. Housing in some major Indian cities is more expensive than many locations in New York or London, as cursory scrutiny of real estate advertising quickly establishes. So, the stories of success and resulting Pharaonic comparative wealth are less true for many middle class NRIs than too readily assumed. Their bumpkin cousins now seem to wield hefty purchasing power and also shop abroad if they fancy. But the issue is not so easily settled and there nags the feeling life is definitely so much better in New York, San Francisco, London and Paris. Quite clearly these cities are superior to live in, much better run and possess better public services. NRIs have a superior life style and perform better in such locations, which have reasonable transport, access to basic services like uninterrupted power supplies, easy availability of essentials like water and fuel for cooking, etc.
However, the socio-economic make-up of emigrants from India has depended on their destination. Migration to the UK was dominated by blue collar workers and they have undoubtedly prospered compared to those they left behind in places like the Punjab. The economic reason for their enhanced living standards is due to the rapid absorption of NRIs in higher productivity jobs compared to what might have been available in India. NRIs were also savers and mostly managed to buy their own homes, which turned out to be a good investment. Professional NRIs like doctors also abound in the UK and benefit from the relatively high salaries of medical practitioners although their highly regarded counterparts in India also do well because of the significant rewards of private practice.
NRIs in the US are very different to Indian migrants settled in the other major destination, the UK. The majority of NRIs in the US are professionals because it has an imperious policy of leeching on the human capital of other societies, especially poorer ones. Professionals belong to an elite class in the profoundly unequal society the US happens to be and are suitably well heeled. Medicine, for instance, is a business like real estate and most doctors are more anxious to become multi millionaires than heal. Successful healing is a by-product of high tech intervention and the threat of legal sanction for failure. This is unfortunately the model that India is also adopting, but one unworthy of emulation. Alas, this is in fact the example of NRI success in the US that subliminally prompts the desire of many in India to imitate it.
Indian NRI business success in the US derives from unique characteristics of their enviable predicament. Those who leave India for US shores are some of its most gifted and highly educated and were likely to have also made good had they remained at home. But the US experience is different in one important respect, which is its much greater wealth, as one of the richest places on earth. Thus, success in business is very much a product of the significantly higher level economic well being the US enjoys. The entrepreneur and inventor in the Silicon Valley operate in a society that already happens to possess a ready market of large numbers of well-to-do customers. It offers a much higher chance that a quality product invented and marketed will sell, making the entrepreneur wealthy. India obviously lags behind in this regard as a society that is at a considerable distance from US living standards. But US society is also highly receptive to creativity and out-of-the-box thinking, rewarding merit unlike India where nepotism and status are prominent.
English: Looking east along Newark Street (India Square) towards JFK Blvd on a sunny late afternoon. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
The fundamental difference between India and the US, where NRIs succeed, is the disparity in their levels of economic development. But it would be foolish not to recognise that India has long been mismanaged as an economy and society. It inherited mediocre politicians after independence, lacking the intellectual wherewithal to comprehend appropriate policy for their impoverished country. Over time, its politics also became thoroughly criminalised and communalised to give the criminals an alibi for grand larceny. Economic policy espoused in the first four decades was also deeply misconceived, hostile to entrepreneurship and envious of success. The future was and remains hostage to errors of past policies and the clientele of beneficiaries created by mindless state control. One particular area of consequential Indian failure has been the inability to nurture scientific endeavour, with the most gifted fleeing abroad to achieve their celebrated successes. The dead hand of the state virtually killed Indian invention and research activity in everything from mathematics and physics to chemistry and the allied sciences. There was success in some areas like space research and atomic energy, but they merely underline the huge failures across the board elsewhere.
Thus, there is more than a grain of truth that NRIs succeed abroad because they function in societies run more rationally and not merely because of the greater prosperity in them. Yet, this inference is a half-truth. Professionals and entrepreneurs are indeed successful in the US and highly rewarded, NRIs also enjoying a share in the prosperity. But US society remains profoundly fissured socio-economically and chronically violent. The US State apparatus also espouses a genocidal instinct towards the non white world outside it. It would be a very brave man who would argue these hugely dominant, negative aspects of US society can be separated and expunged and only the phenomenon of entrepreneurial success, which admirers of NRIs within it extol, preserved. It would not be too harsh to judge the US an exceedingly sick society in many respects and more reprehensible morally because the disease co-exists with massive intellectual and material resources.
Indian flag and the State Emblem atop Vidhana Soudha in Bengaluru (Bangalore). (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
India has now embarked on the stony path to remedy the missteps of past decades and the mundane policy changes necessary to embark on it evident in recent months. Vested interests that emerged from past state patronage and the unholy political nexus that has accompanied it must be confronted without ceremony. Their moral standing is nearly zero and self interest alone their signature tune. And the gods have evidently decided enough is enough and, quite remarkably, the man likely to chart a new course for Indian society and its economy is at the helm. The slogan of ‘Make in India’ is laudable though the precise contours to achieve complex since more than 40 percent of the Indian economy is now in traded goods and there is no going back. Indian success will reverse the shocking brain drain it experiences, but effective policies can be implemented to mitigate its cost and end the Indian subsidy to the richest society in history.
India remains poor, but the survival of its democracy is a resounding affirmation of the fundamental decency of its society. There is much to lament and criticise and even more to improve. But it is possible to commend the huge effort that has been made in sixty seven years of Indian independence for the socio-economic upliftment of those who suffered the most egregious disadvantages. These advances occurred while India’s population rose more than three-fold, without the famines earlier routine. There is still a considerable distance to traverse in many areas, especially in the treatment meted out to women and widespread malnourishment, but a huge churning is occurring that augurs well for India’s future. India will never be as materially rich as the US although a good number of its people will achieve living standards to equal it. The sharing of a more modest of life will require ‘man making’, if only to assure social harmony to mitigate possible discord the need to accept it may provoke. In the end, Indian civilisation is not about endless wealth through unlimited exploitation of others and nature. The integral human is the product of reaching towards self-realisation and that worthy goal of Sanatan Dharma is an imperative yearning that defines Indian society.
[…] Do Indians prosper only abroad? […]
I recall the handsome Gautam Sen, whom the ladies drooled over, from my time at the LSE more than 30 years back.
He had a very good reputation of helping ordinary working people- for example from Nepal.
The true Hindu Academic makes no distinction between ‘elite’ and ‘worker’, or ‘my student’ & ‘not my problem’. All young people should be helped equally. I hope other Hindu Academics will follow this example.
I don’t know if Dr. Sen is from Calcutta. Perhaps he knows this couplet of Mast Kalkattavi
voh phuul sar chaRhaa jo chaman se nikal gayaa
izzat use milii jo vatan se nikal gayaa
(http://socioproctology.blogspot.co.uk/2010/07/motto-of-nri.html)
However, I must mention that many who have gained glory in foreign lands were pushed out of India. Before Independence, young freedom fighters had to flee abroad from the C.I.D.
After Independence, they were pushed out less brutally in the name of ‘Social Justice’.
License Permit Raj was one face of this coin. Other face was ‘Quota’ which actually meant ‘Pull’.
The Chief Coroner who gained deserved fame from O.J Simpson trial, Phil Spector case and Michael Jackson autopsy is an example of ‘Indian who made good abroad’. But that gentleman- a very simple and sweet person who longed only to remain close to his Mum & Dad to serve them (he was only son) was forced out of India. Doesn’t matter that he was ‘topper’ at young age. Wrong Caste- not that Caste matters if you have ‘Pull’ or your Daddy is Rich. But his father was a patriotic Indian Army Doctor. What chance did the boy have?
One proud gentleman came to see me many years ago. “My son is a good cook. Please take him abroad with you and settle him.’ I explained I was a nobody myself but could certainly find a rich family of good character to employ him. But, when I saw the boy I was amazed at his intelligence. ‘Do you want scholarship or chef job?’ I asked him. He immediately became proud. He said ‘I want chef job. In ten years I will earn enough to send my brothers and sister to Private Medical College. My father wished this for me but it is impossible. If you can help, do so. Otherwise don’t talk to me about Scholarships.’ I was intimidated. This family was known to mine as very proud and of ancient renown. The fellow went on a proper visa with good wages to a top restaurant run by a highly professional and decent Sindhi. He has not only fulfilled his father’s wish three times over- three Doctors in the family- but they have all done Post Grad in America or Europe and returned home and are living like Kings.
But, in my eyes, it is a tragic story. This man wanted to be a Doctor. His intelligence was much higher. Had he become Doctor, his marriage would have been with highly accomplished lady of social standing. Instead, he married an uneducated girl to look after parents and could only visit once in two years. He had heart attack at the young age of 48. Wife came here to look after him but they are living in ‘Council Flat’. Wife had two miscarriages. I am not a Medical man. But, how can the birth be easeful for the eldest daughter-in-law when husband is far away? In our culture, all the stresses and strains are put on her shoulder.
This childless couple, living in a grey and cheerless ‘Council Block’- are they happy? Amazingly enough- Yes!
I didn’t know. For a long time, I had my doubts and felt sad for my caste-fellow.
You see, when the lady first came here she would come to my place and do cleaning and some cooking. I didn’t understand she wanted to be paid so I was initially flustered. But she sullenly chased me away when I tried to help. The she went and stood at the door with her fist resting on her hip. It was the posture of the maid-servant waiting to be paid. I was greatly relieved. I paid and asked when she could come next. She said to me in a sort of Hindi, not Tamil, ‘tell your Gujerati friends. I do cleaning and vegetarian cooking. This money is enough.’
I got on the phone immediately and won golden opinions from Hindu housewives in the neighbouring locality of Knightsbridge by supplying them with this gem of a domestic.
Two months later, the lady came to me with a fat wad of notes. I was to set up a Bank account for her and transmit money to her relatives. By this time, I was very frightened of her.
Still, I asked questions. Why this subterfuge?
In contemptuous ‘Madras’ Tamil she explained. Her family too were Brahmins. They too dreamt of becoming Doctors. Do as you are told.
Terrified, I complied.
I have said that her husband’s family was known to mine. They were Freedom Fighters and proud people.
No doubt both husband and wife looked down on me. I’m uneducated. I order meat dishes from restaurants, I restock my bar religiously, I waste money on Surround systems and 4k Tv.
Yet both had no option but to trust me and take my help.
Why?
Their Caste had become a stick to beat them with in the name of Social Justice. Their only way forward was to find the most ignorant and filthiest fellow caste member to help them take ‘filthy’ jobs so that…what? they could live ‘swanky N.R.I. lives?’
No Dr. Sen.
These people are living in London but leading wholly Hindu lives.
If you want to see ‘swanky life-styles’ look at the husband’s younger siblings. The wife also has sent back so much money, her siblings are now fixed on the same path.
Probably, any middle aged N.R.I like myself can narrate not one but ten stories like this.
In sabak-e-hindi poetry, the dancing peacock is not the harbinger of life-giving Monsoonal rain, but the one whose narcissism has trapped it in that Avalon of an Eden where ‘falls no rain nor ever the winds blow loudly’.
On a day of hail and snow and a banshee wind, guiltily recalling how grey is their residence, I suddenly saw that the Indian peacock dances for them in their unlovely Council flat.
The flower that adorns the tresses of True Beauty was never plucked from its natal garden. Rather there is only this Jungle of Maya in which the peacock so dances that Heaven’s tears obliterate the distinction between N.R and I.
“In the end, Indian civilisation is not about endless wealth through unlimited exploitation of others and nature.”
A culture which celebrates laxmi every year and loves its gold is not about “endless wealth”? And who said US is about that? What lies! US was found on property + individual rights, their wealth is merely a consequence of that.
That’s both an excuse and a rationalization for our failures, also saying US society is “sick” is sick without giving any actual points as in what you find so sick.
Say whatever you like, but we can not achieve a decent quality of life unless we control our increasing numbers. We are just not creating enough resources to cater the exponential increase in population. No matter what social schemes the government brings, there would always be a huge segment of population that would remain in the have-nots segment. This is also affecting the social fabric in terms of raising aggression levels and indiscipline. Everybody, who is in a position to hoard resources, in whatever form, is doing so, just to maintain that standard of living and perhaps, to elevate it. While there may be wide gaps in economic conditions of people in western societies too, however, they are based on certain fundamentals, for instance, discipline, fear of law & a raised collective conscience of a society. We, unfortunately, just wear jingoism on our sleeves, but the nationalistic spirit is not reflected in our actions. This trend is more pronounced in our bigger cities as compared to smaller towns.