Published On: Mon, May 19th, 2014

Narendra Modi’s challenge to Islam

Narendra Modi poses the greatest challenge to Islam since modern Turkey’s Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, perhaps an even greater one. This has been understood perfectly by adherents to the marginal Wahhabi sect that has come to dominate Sunni Islam. These are the subversive purveyors of evil from the desert kingdom, symbols of arrogance and financial sponsors of global terror, put into power by the retreating British and sustained ever since by US imperial design. They and the worldwide clerical as well as secular retainers of their patronage and largesse are justly alarmed by the Modi phenomenon. Even a cursory look at contemporary Gujarat explains why Narendra Modi arouses such anxiety and wholehearted loathing.

After a dozen years as Gujarat’s chief minister, despite being maligned and libelled on an industrial scale, he has apparently struck a chord with its Muslims. All the perverse propaganda and incitement to terror against Narendra Modi personally, by his supposedly mainstream opponents, has not convinced all Gujarati Muslims that he is the devil incarnate. The have begun voting for him in growing numbers on the basis of the evidence before their very own eyes. They like good governance, development and an atmosphere of efficient purposefulness that is not scarred indelibly by widespread corruption. The absence of riots, which the poor Muslim most earnestly desires, is also a daily lived experience that all the malicious fabrications against Narendra Modi cannot dispel.

It is this phenomenon that has caused deep alarm among the conservative Muslim clergy. Muslims voting for good governance and economic development are an unprecedented challenge to their age-old, traditional authority, buttressed by the slogan ‘Islam in danger’. Their determined upholding of every vestige of India’s historical status quo, however irrational and indeed unjust is underpinned by cultivating fear and ignorance.

The dangerous chief minister of Gujarat, a man without elevated lineage or any recognisable signs of divinity, is poised put all this to the sword. He is offering the ordinary Muslim as well as countless others a peaceful life and a modicum of prosperity. And they are all showing more than passing interest in this seductive menu of choice offered.

India’s political class and its vast network of beneficiaries have also sensed the beginnings of a revolution that spells their own doom. Indian politics is essentially pure entrepreneurialism and the unashamed opportunism of the political class. Like used cars salesman and corrupt real estate dealers, there is nothing they are unprepared to do to sell themselves. The arousal of fear, mainly directed at Muslims and patent electoral bribery are their twin devices of befuddlement and deceit. Yet the sheer size of the growing electoral constituency needed to gain political power is too large to satisfy by robbing the public purse. Their vain attempt has brought the country to its knees, pretty much bankrupting the public exchequer. The outcome has been worsened because the massive buying-off provided too many opportunities for personal enrichment for politicians to ignore.

Narendra Modi is the oddball who is refusing to play their game and aspires to higher goals they find unfathomably indecent. Most frightening of all, after one successful term of good governance, Narendra Modi will split the minority vote bank permanently and commence their indefinite political oblivion.

The Indian media is unequivocally an appendage of its corrupt politics, lacking professionalism and honour. In recent days one television channel has taken to only showing films starring a particularly offensive ruling party candidate. The so-called Indian intelligentsia and its monstrous Anglicised incarnation is a standing reminder of John K. Galbraith’s pithy comment that whenever the intelligentsia is in unanimous agreement something is deeply amiss! The Indian intelligentsia is seeking to provide some form of moral and cognitive ballast for a rotten and corrupt politics by singing hymns on secularism and communal sins. But even mobilising their foreign supporters, waving personal banners of international status is failing to wash, when the standard bearers of such blessed principles are the likes of Laloo Prasad and the irrepressible Robert Vadra. In any case, these spin masters are in reality often unread and ignorant and forlornly hope that the masses they seek to brainwash will be none the wiser!

The threat to Islam posed by Modi’s modernising drive, turning India into a unified nation with a common purpose, is also deeply worrisome to its adversaries and even putative ‘friends’. Divide and rule, by tweaking every division and inserting nefarious purposes into every social fissure, has been the age-old imperial stratagem to keep India weak and achieve their goals. And Narendra Modi is threatening to challenge this blissful arrangement.

But worse, for the desert Arab kingdom and its profoundly destructive impact across the world, with the mass murder of Shia Muslims and mayhem from Nigeria and Mali to Thailand and China being their trademark, what does the modernity of Indian Sunnis mean to their exercise of unhindered control over the faithful? The loss of a significant segment of Indian Muslims to the hated allurements of modernity and women’s rights is the beginning of the end.

The slightly barmy obsessions of prominent sections of India’s Muslim clergy, entertained in few other Muslim countries, have been calculated to nurture division and fear to ensure the loyalty of a fearful minority population. The expansion of the Kolkata airport was held to ransom by a solitary mosque for decades, causing untold economic damage to the city. Mosques, it was argued cannot ever be touched although that is clearly not so in Muslim countries. Its move elsewhere has now been agreed, but only after vast compensation was extracted by a sullen local religious leadership. In the place of crass manipulation by religious leaders, the enticement of a peaceful life of freedom and personal attainment promises to create irresistible inducements for Muslims worldwide. This is the reason why Narendra Modi’s programme of change is feared. Mustafa Kemal Ataturk’s unsparing drive to modernise has stalled in contemporary Turkey, but dramatic change in an urbanised India, on the threshold of socio-economic modernity, is likely to be enduring.

And India will become a potent example to Muslims everywhere of freedom and prosperity.

(The author taught international political economy at the London School of Economics and Political Science for more than two decades.)

About the Author

- Dr. Gautam Sen taught international political economy at the London School of Economics and Political Science for over two decades.


Displaying 20 Comments
Have Your Say
  1. renu s says:

    Such a well written article! Why Bhartiyas are not putting up an intitute of Westology?
    It can bring about a sea change in how the west is seen by youngsters the world over.

  2. prasad says:

    Siraj is right. The one with a Hindu looking name should do some home work to know the true message of islam,especially jihad. islam is jihad. without jihad islam cannot survive. and jihad is out and out armed war waged against non-muslims. it is no non-combative striving as dubiously propagated by ignorant and mischivous people like. to know the true import of jihad, one should read authentic jihad manuals. for example read this one by the name ‘the book of jihad’ by Ibn Nuhas. its original name is ‘mashari’ in short. if the ignoramuses who consider islam to be what they mouth, let them read the hadith collections by Al-Bukhari, Muslim or Tirmidhi to know the true face of islam. till then let them not drool about what they do not know.

  3. jayesh patel says:

    Vivek Hattangadi your name suggests you are not a Muslim nor have studied the Koran. Please watch this video BY AN ISLAMIC SCHOLAR on Islam and Jihad. May need to copy n paste http://youtu.be/_HNNgKiGyWE

  4. Rex says:

    Minor nitpick – Mustafa Kemal successfully turned Turkey around from a feudal, backward Islamic society to a modern truly secular one, and it stayed that way for decades. Now they’re just inexplicably going into reverse gear back to the 7th century.

  5. Max says:

    Psuedo-intellectualism (if there is a word like that) at its best! There is a saying that comes to my mind: Allah meherban to gadha pehelwan!

  6. Excellent article! Truth written like a blazing sword!How one wishes the Nehruvian papilons had met a contender like Modi in the sixtes or the seventies to challange their deceitful hegemony. My present fear is that this lot is going to join the bjp and do their sabotage from within! But i have faith in Modi. He will not budge.Thanks to the writer of the article. Wish i had written it. I hope against hope that the great and much pampered left wing bengali intelligentsia (Amarty sen Sir …n the rest) at least try to concede the brutal truth of their tacit support to a imminent muslim majority west bengal and Assam by 2030.

  7. kareem says:

    On the same length and breadth. Modi must call Hindus sloging in Arab land. He must not forget india sucks 40 billion USD from these so called muslim world which is more than what india earns from the whole IT industry

    • Interstellar says:

      It is not India who sucks 40Billion USD from these countries. It is the people (indians) who makes that much.
      IT industry generates revenue in India and Govt also gets a share of it in the form of direct and indirect taxes.
      Hence the comparison doesnt hold good brother.

    • Kalit says:

      Poorly paid, abused and many dying, the migrant labour in the Arab world earns their bitter fruit the hard way. Most Indians are not in the vile Wahabbi kingdom, but the lazy Arabs, who only have Allah and oil, will be up the creek without migrant labour. They do everything for these abominable creatures, from running their economy to tying their proverbial shoe laces!

  8. Hanuman says:

    The author Dr Gautam sen is heavily featured in this documentary by Dr Manish pandit.
    The documentary unravels a crucial case that attempted to indict Modi by proving a terrorist as an innocent.
    Dr Gautam Sen’s remarks are brilliant as usual

    http://vimeo.com/90870480

    For more info on the movie you may contact @mmpandit on twitter

  9. Siraj says:

    I give a very few Quran verses and would any Wahabi or Sunni or their other 71 Islamic sects give the real import of words and still calling themselves as peace lovers?
    Muslims should never to sincere to their words. It is called TAQQUIASH as per their own Islamic trilogy Quran, Hadiths and Sira.
    Various Islamic Quotes can be given at lengh for Taqquiah and Jihad
    IF TAQQUIAH AND JIHAD IS NO MORE ISLAM WOULD BE DEAD THAT VERY MOMENT.
    Still Pakistan want peace take with no preconditions.
    There is a Urdu Shairi: Here I quote
    ”दिल न मिल पाये तो, फिर, आंख बचा कर चल दो ।
    बेसबब हाथ मिलाने कि, ज़रूरत क्या है ||””
    Meaning,
    ”Where our hearts do not meet on any point, just go away.
    What purpose will it serve by mere shaking of hands, all to go in vain ultimately?”

    QURAN 5.33
    PICKTHAL: The only reward of those who make war upon Allah and His messenger and strive after corruption in the land will be that they will be killed or crucified, or have their hands and feet on alternate sides cut off, or will be expelled out of the land. Such will be their degradation in the world, and in the Hereafter theirs will be an awful doom;
    Quran 8.39
    YUSUFALI: And fight them on until there is no more tumult or oppression, and there
    prevail justice and faith in Allah altogether and everywhere; but if they cease, verily
    Allah doth see all that they do.
    QURAN 9.005
    YUSUFALI: But when the forbidden months are past, then fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, an seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war); but if they repent, and establish regular prayers and practise regular charity, then open the way for them: for Allah is Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful.

  10. A balanced article. The Holy Koran has never propagated violence.

    One of the most manipulated concepts in Islam today is the concept of jihad.

    The concept of jihad is indeed a Quranic one, but sadly, a false and twisted version of this Quranic concept has been used by terrorists acting in the name of Islam to commit various terrorist acts. These terrorist acts, which occur all over the world, aim at the indiscriminate killing of innocent people. They are being undertaken in the name of “jihad”. These non-Islamic acts have gone a long way towards distorting the image of Islam.

    As with any religious concept, it’s correct definition lies in the scripture and not in the interpretation of humans. To fully understand the Quranic concept of jihad, it is essential to address the ‘The Quranic definition of the word jihad’

    The literal definition of the word jihad is: striving to achieve a goal, while the Quranic definition of the word is “striving with one’s self and one’s money in the cause of God”.

    • Shubhangi says:

      The article is indeed balanced and very relevent for Muslims in India. What Vivek says about Jehad is questionable. Also Islam accepts conversion by coersion and even aggression. These are implicitly violent actions

    • rahul singh says:

      You haven’t a clue what you are talking about. An unsolicited but great advice for you from a poster I saw way back in school, ‘It is better to keep your mouth shut and let others guess if you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubts’.
      No need to thank me, just following it ie. not providing your two cents on an issue you have never been able to comprehend, will more than do for all concerned.

  11. harihara says:

    Modi is looking at indians and not at some digma. let us talk about development and show the evolutionary dynamism of peole of this ancient civilization; Let vipraas to do bahudhaa vadanti and as such Islam is basically the dwairtic relationship between thge creator an created. We could rather spend time in thinking how to reuce prices

  12. Kali says:

    Article written before elections had concluded, on 28th April and inference based on Gujarat assembly polls, as indicated.

  13. Nowgong(assam) 50% muslim pop, Raipur(chhattisgarh) – >61% muslims,bijnor > 40, rampur > 40 and many such other constituencies won by BJP and many with big margins…all this just prove that muslims have voted heavily in favour of BJP.

    • Lakshmi says:

      Wonderful and illuminating write-up. Wish you would send this to one of the major newspapers in India and DARE them to publish it !!

  14. Hi,
    I have read somewhere that in two constituencies with over 50% muslim population BJP candidates have won. Have been trying to find out but unable to do so. Only when you put out such examples and more, will your article sound more convincing. Right now it sounds a lot of theory.

Leave a comment