Published On: Mon, Nov 17th, 2014

Read this before swallowing the secularist drumbeat about Haryana Khaps

Over the last four or so years, the mainstream discourse about Haryana has proceeded along these lines: Haryana is the worst state in India and the Jats there are the vilest. The Khap Panchayat is an evil medieval-feudal system characterized by misogyny, is against love and brutally enforces its writ against erring members of the community.

This mainstream discourse carefully omits history—Haryana derives its name from “Hari,” who in his avatar as Krishna delivered the Bhagavad Gita on its soil. This discourse also conceals the enormously significant contribution of these Jats: that they always remained fiercely independent and stood up to the tyranny of the Mughals and never changed their religion under duress. This discourse also omits mentioning the fact that the British were always vary of them and ruled them indirectly—and like the much-maligned Thugges, ran a calculated and vicious slander campaign vilifying them.

jats

And the English media, which has inherited this same colonial disdain for everything native—and schooled mostly under the “convent education” scheme of things—simply is content to utter grand pronouncements on things they neither understand nor care about. Indeed, most of the Delhi-based news houses apparently do not have enough fuel or the need to travel away from Noida to create TRP news. Most of these worthies don’t even know from where and  how the milk comes for their morning tea.

And so they need and pick on the easiest of targets—the faceless farmer of Haryana, who feeds 30 per cent of India but cannot speak and articulate to defend the honour of his community and people. The media and secularists show their gratitude by branding such folk as Khap Taliban whose only job is to go around committing honour killings.

khap

And then there’s the other oft-talked point about female foeticide.  In the media’s eyes, it is Haryana and Haryana alone where female foeticide occurs, and the state therefore cannot be pardoned for its sins—all people of Haryana need to be shamed nationally. Jats especially should be shamed for suppressing their women.

Women form 22 per cent of Haryana, a state which is home to two per cent of the national population. But what the media doesn’t tell is the fact that these people continue to garner 40 per cent of medal tally in all various sports where they represent India.

And then in the wake of the Muzaffarnagar riots, the media introduced a new spin: they were no longer Hindu-Muslim riots. They morphed into Jat-Muslim riots. In one fell swoop, these beleaguered farmers no longer had a religion they could call their own.

Welcome to the new media where Judge Arnab Goswami and a handful of National Commission for Women members decide the fate of the Jats. And assuming there’s a shortage of food grains, vegetables, milk etc, the same Judges and Juries will blame the same Jats because they didn’t treat their women well and therefore, farm production declined.

This is only a different facet of the same ugly reality spawned by Indian secularism where the rustic and the real natives get their lives, thoughts, mores, lifestyles, thoughts, and even honour scripted by a few talking heads on TV. The subtext of the narrative is this: Khap Panchayats/Jats don’t have the language to control their own future and the media looks down upon people who don’t know English, and even worse, won’t give them the voice to defend themselves.

The only way they will be heard is when they agree to come under say, a ‘Rajiv Gandhi Jat Lok Laaj Bachao Yojna’ produced and directed by the likes of NAC. Until then, they will be castigated by the likes of Barkha Dutt and company.

Indeed, do the media ever mention the fact that the Jats were the first to accept widow marriages? Jat women on the ‘Population-Medal Ratio’ fare better than their Australian counterparts.

jat women

Does the media also mention the fact that in the Hissar region, there is blanket ban on sending women for field labour in some Gotras? What it does mention is this: what is this Gotra System? Jats and other communities across the country prohibit same Gotra marriages as a check against inbreeding, a practice dating centuries ago. But a western professor at say the University of Leicester deems it primitive and backward, and lo and behold! Our media parrots this expert.

Everybody in Haryana knows that the Khaaps are the largest game organisers and it is the substrate that gets India all those international medals, but does the media mention it?

Even as we speak, a strict code is being developed by Khaap Panchayats regarding Women’s Safety in local buses, and they are far more effective than what passes off for law and order in the country.

Oh! The same Haryana that is home to these regressive Khap Panchayats invests the maximum in education, but the media only sees honour killings.

In the end, I leave the reader with this couplet:

Krishna ne UP mein Bansi bajwaayee hogi,

Haryana mein to Jhoot bajwaaye !

(Krishna played the flute in UP, in Haryana, he went to war).

About the Author


Displaying 14 Comments
Have Your Say
  1. hahaha.. this is hilarious.
    so medals > life of women. this article gave me an idea to do a mash-up of ‘300’ and ‘the hunger games’. its like sparta (where infants not strong enough were killed, according to the movie anyways) with female medal winners go to hunger games to win for the honor of hookah-smoking patriarchs.
    also.. this gem: “Women form 22 per cent of Haryana, a state which is home to two per cent of the national population.”

  2. NK Sarma says:

    Article of poor standards. Pls don’t dilute the quality and reputation of other indiafacts authors. I was hoping for a write up on the good things from Khap panchayats, but disappointed to see this article talking about Jats and their sports and slightly touching upon Khap. This article is a sitting duck for seculars. I wonder what khap has to do with medals in sports. Khap panchayats are a practical solution to the lethargic and flawed indian justice system. Where this is no khap, its the rowdys, corporators and crimnals who run the panchayats for money. Khaps on the other hand is not for money, but for justice and well being of the community however traditional it is. The intent is clearly to do what is right. Local dada and rowdy panchayats have intent to make money and no govt or media can pluck even their hair, nevermind dismantling them. Indian police and the lawyers are the poorest quality professionals who take up these jobs out of no other option. These people don’t have sense of justice, but only do the job for sake of living. Its foolish to expect govt and law to be effective in villages with this kind of bad quality of police and lawyers. Khaps are different, justice is delivered fast and with quality, keeping in mind overall well being and long term protection. It would have been fair if the author asked the newstraders not to make a mountain out of one or two misjudgement and to look at the million other judgements instead to see their effectiveness. But the author failed miserably.

  3. Shubhangi Raykar says:

    Ban on marriages within same Gotra is practiced among many Hindus.The Gotra refers to the first ancestor of whom you are the progeny.So the belief is that in a way you are siblings. the likes of Urnab Goswamis are not likely to know this.

    • parwatisingari says:

      And what makes you so sure, I am not an Arnab goswami fan, I think he should be silenced, but do not assuming that the other person is ignorant.

      • Shubhangi Raykar says:

        What makes me so sure about about Arnab Goswami’s ignorance about the Sagotra concept or what statement I made earlier? It is just a possibility that he may not know this or may be he knows it and he finds the whole thing ridiculous.There are many things to which one may not subscribe but one has no business to ridicule it. About the earlier statement, I know of priests who refused to perform the rituals of Sagotra marriages until 50 years ago or even later.
        A friend of mine was getting married to someone from the same gotra and our family priest refused to perform the wedding rites. When i asked him, he said that would be like marrying brother and sister because when we belong to the same Gotra we are the progeny of the same Rishi. He was a learned man having spent 12 or more years in Banaras studying Dashgranthas. He also knew that after so many years have passed the genetic issue should not be there but he believed in certain dos and don’ts when he had to be a part of the ceremony and he had his individual right to say ‘No’. He did not stop any one else from doing so.

  4. parwatisingari says:

    How do you justify honour killing?

    • Rightway14 says:

      well you don’t..but why do you think its only in Haryana??

    • NK Sarma says:

      which khap ordered honor killing and how many of the 150000 khap cases per year had this verdict? Question is how do you justify the existence of your brain?
      Anyway, honor killing is a way of life in muslim community. In their case, they typically kill the son-in-law and not the daughter. So morons don’t call it honor killing and call it a dispute and suspected murder. Sometimes even that much attention is not given, like the case of Rakesh Sharma of Jammu. A few coward hindus who kill their daughters with excuse of their honor is used by media to foulmouth hindus and khaps, which they keep their tool tucked inside when it comes to blatant murders by muslims. Well, nevertheless, it needs brain to anallyse and understand these .

      • parwatisingari says:

        Your are quiet obnoxious Mr.Sarma, but maybe you have point.This is a sincere request the only way to shut Arnab goswami is to stitch his mouth up. The same goes for Rajdeep Sardesai, Bak-bak Dutt and I wish it was Sagarika goes instead of ghosh. Having said that Mr.Sarma how about sharing the good information on Khap panchayat. One thing I can think of is decentralization which is the need of the hour.

        • NK Sarma says:

          got provoked by your one liner on honor killing, my apologies. Please note my other comment on Khap about my view on Khap.

  5. Kishan Sharma says:

    Shobhaji, its a very well argued piece. Your point about the ban on same gotra marriages is very valid. It is a scientifically proven principle that in-breeding is always to be avoided to keep any community healthy.Genetic defects have started appearing in Muslim communities where marriages with even first cousins are allowed. So here also the Jat community is on firmer ground scientifically, when they avoid same gotra marriages. Even among brahmins in Haryana, we always chose the match for a girl/boy from a different village 15/20 KM away from the bride’s/groom’s village. Any plant breeder will also tell you that a cross between two genetically different seeds is always stronger in most respects.

    • parwatisingari says:

      Sorry Mr.Kishan Sharma, the genetic factor came in much later. Intially the Gotras were about intellect and area of research. As for in-breeding which is a rather crude word, it can happen when cousins of different gothras marry.

  6. Sat Kumar Tomer says:

    Thanks for writing the article.

Leave a comment