Muslims in Gujarat Poorer: NYT

Assertion: In its editorial on 26 October 2013, the New York Times makes the following claim:

[Narendra Modi's] economic record in Gujarat is not entirely admirable, either. Muslims in Gujarat, for instance, are much more likely to be poor than Muslims in India as a whole…

As evidence of this claim, the NYT links to a Press Note issued by the Government of India's Planning Commission published in March 2012.


The aforementioned Press Note provides data on poverty estimates for the year 2009-2010 for the entire country. However, this Press Note is not the latest data on the subject. The New York Times should have based its assertion on the latest data, which the Planning Commission has released for 2011-12.

Surjit Bhalla has provided a detailed analysis of the latest figures showing the economic condition of Muslims in Gujarat. The following table (drawn from Mr. Bhalla's analysis) shows this analysis:

GujMuslimsIt is emphatically clear from the data that the poverty level of Gujarat's Muslims, which stood at 39.4% in 1999-2000 and 37.6% in 2009-10 has declined to a mere 11.4% in 2011-12. The poverty level of Muslims nationally stands at 25.5%.

The NYT editorial also reports India's Muslim population as 138 million whereas the fact is that at about 14.6% of India's total population, Muslims make up for about 176 million people.


It is quite clear that the New York Times has failed to do due diligence on even simple, basic things like economic and population figures. The result is an editorial that violates the elementary journalistic ethic of verifying facts before publishing them as truth.

IndiaFacts verdict: False.

Deprecated: file_exists(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($filename) of type string is deprecated in /home/ on line 1617


    October 29, 2013

    Arun Kumar

    Does it matter? what is NYT in front of the people of India- a toilet paper more likely. For Modi biaters and haters NYT was always there but they no longer count if they ever did.

      February 19, 2015

      Venkat Sundaram

      I thought toilet paper title was given to TOI by Dr. Swamy

    October 29, 2013

    Lalit Ambardar

    NYT has no problems in promoting views of anti India Kashmiri Islamists but ignores comments exposing their terror infested Pak sponsored Kashmir Jihad that at outset in 1989-90 saw bloody ethnic cleansing of aboriginal Kashmiri Pandits

    October 28, 2013


    I was under the impression that the English Language media in India only was against Narendra Modi and are attuned to distorting all facts. This article shows that they have their friends in the US as well. Anyway, whatever these intelligent people write, it is more or less a foregone conclusion that the government is going to change, come the results of the 2014 General Elections.